Melanie:
I had just finished filing my statement about the case with my professor, Dr. Lurie, when I heard the phone ring. It was my father. “Hello Melanie, I was just calling to tell you Mr. Lurie’s trial is going to be next week and soon this whole thing will be settled.” “Thank you I just was just finishing writing my statement when you called.” “Is there something wrong? You sound sad” he asked. “No I just cant believe I let something like this happen to me.” “OK I’m sorry but make sure you let them know how you really feel so that they can make the right decision.” A week later David Lurie sat in front of the heads of the university justice department. He refused to read the statement that I had taken so much time to write.
From David’s point of view of this situation he thinks that Melanie was forced to file the statement against him. From this point of view you can clearly see that it was Melanie’s choice to say that David was wrong in his actions. From this view Melanie still does not get a voice at the trial. I choose to do this because she is a very passive girl. She lets David easily take her over the first night that they spend together. She is also has a boyfriend who takes control of her and want to have everything go his way.
Sunday, May 17, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This was well done. One thing that would have made your post stronger would have been to add more detail. For example, you could mention how Laurie's position of power may have caused Melanie to be more passive than she normally would have been.
ReplyDeleteYou did make a strong point with your choice of analyzing David Lurie's refusal to read Melanie's statement. It would make your analysis stronger if you include more details by referring more to the events in the novel.
ReplyDelete