In James Joyce’s story “Araby” the boy tricked by his friend’s sister, which he has a crush on, to go to the bazaar. The boy has always been too shy to talk to the sister until one night when she spoke to him. She asked him if he was going to araby. He says if he goes that he will bring her back something. The boy is excited to go t the bazaar and get the girl something. The trip to the bazaar takes longer then the boy had anticipated. First he has to wait for his father to come home so that he can get money, then he takes the train to the gallery. When he finally gets there half the lights are out, no one is around, and half of the booths are already closed. He sees a stall with vases and flowered tea sets. He wanders over only to be ignored by the woman who is flirting behind the counter. When she finally notices him he refuses to buy anything. The woman goes back to flirting while the boy just stands in front of the stall paralyzed. A few minutes later the lights of the gallery go out and he is left standing in the middle. At this point the boy has an epiphany that vanity and material objects can control us.
In Joyce’s other story “Eveline” the main character faces a similar dilemma to that of “Araby”. She is forced to make a decision about something and at the last minute is paralyzed when she realizes she is making the wrong decision. Eveline is faced with the decision of staying with her family and memories or sailing away with frank to Buenos Ayres. She decides to go with Frank and start fresh in a new place. As the boat is approaching the dock Frank grabs Eveline’s hand beckoning her to board the boat. She is paralyzed as he drags her close to the boat. Just before she steps foot on the boat she realizes that she cannot leave these things behind. She grabs hold of the railings with both hands refuses to board the boat just like the boy in “Araby” refuses to buy something.
In both stories the characters are forced to make decisions about certain things. In one case it is as little as buying something for a girl and in the other it is much larger as in Eveline’s case of starting a new life. Both characters think they know what they want to do until the time comes for them to actually act. When they are about to act, they are stopped as if paralyzed by their thoughts. Once the paralysis ends they experience an epiphany in which they realize what the right thing to do is.
Sunday, May 17, 2009
a view from the other side
Melanie:
I had just finished filing my statement about the case with my professor, Dr. Lurie, when I heard the phone ring. It was my father. “Hello Melanie, I was just calling to tell you Mr. Lurie’s trial is going to be next week and soon this whole thing will be settled.” “Thank you I just was just finishing writing my statement when you called.” “Is there something wrong? You sound sad” he asked. “No I just cant believe I let something like this happen to me.” “OK I’m sorry but make sure you let them know how you really feel so that they can make the right decision.” A week later David Lurie sat in front of the heads of the university justice department. He refused to read the statement that I had taken so much time to write.
From David’s point of view of this situation he thinks that Melanie was forced to file the statement against him. From this point of view you can clearly see that it was Melanie’s choice to say that David was wrong in his actions. From this view Melanie still does not get a voice at the trial. I choose to do this because she is a very passive girl. She lets David easily take her over the first night that they spend together. She is also has a boyfriend who takes control of her and want to have everything go his way.
I had just finished filing my statement about the case with my professor, Dr. Lurie, when I heard the phone ring. It was my father. “Hello Melanie, I was just calling to tell you Mr. Lurie’s trial is going to be next week and soon this whole thing will be settled.” “Thank you I just was just finishing writing my statement when you called.” “Is there something wrong? You sound sad” he asked. “No I just cant believe I let something like this happen to me.” “OK I’m sorry but make sure you let them know how you really feel so that they can make the right decision.” A week later David Lurie sat in front of the heads of the university justice department. He refused to read the statement that I had taken so much time to write.
From David’s point of view of this situation he thinks that Melanie was forced to file the statement against him. From this point of view you can clearly see that it was Melanie’s choice to say that David was wrong in his actions. From this view Melanie still does not get a voice at the trial. I choose to do this because she is a very passive girl. She lets David easily take her over the first night that they spend together. She is also has a boyfriend who takes control of her and want to have everything go his way.
Saturday, May 16, 2009
David's change
In the novel Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee David Lurie changes as the novel progresses. While he is a professor at the university his entire life revolves around women and his experiences with them. He is a womanizer and doesn’t see things other than his point of view. Once he has his encounter with Melanie things start to go downhill. He is “caught with his pants down” and is tried by the heads of the university. The members of the board told him that if he admitted to the act and told his story that he would most likely get way with his job. He refuses to admit because he doesn’t want to admit that it was wrong. Admitting that he was wrong would put things in a different perspective that he is not able to handle. As he is asked to leave his job he goes to the country to visit his daughter. During his visit with her the changes start to occur. The main experience that changes him in the country is the assault that he experienced while he was there. His daughter was raped and he was burnt. This brought him into perspective with his past and how he has treated women. The animals at the clinic also have a large part in his change. He starts to care for them and some of that translates to his personal life. His position in society also causes a change in him. This aspect does not appear until David meets Petrus, Lucy’s worker, for the first time. Petrus wants to eventually take over Lucy’s farm from her. David does not like this idea and only thinks that Lucy should take care of it. Davis is shocked when he finds out that he is trying to blackmail Lucy into giving it to petrus. It seems that Davis thinks this because petrus is an African American while he himself is white.
Tuesday, May 5, 2009
Emily Grierson is wondering why everyone thinks her father is dead
Name: Emily Grierson
Location: Yoknapatawpha County, Mississippi
Hobbies: In my free time I like to sit around my house, stare at people through my window and paint. I used to teach china painting classes to the younger kids of the town until I shut them out.
Status: I am “married” to a man named Homer Barron, he is a Yankee.
Wall Posts:
Neighbor: Dear Emily, I am really sorry to hear about your father he was a good man to this town. Best of luck to you! P.S. your house is starting to smell really bad, can you please get it checked?
Emily: My father isn’t dead and my house smells fine I don’t know what you could possibly be smelling.
Neighbor: You should thank those kind men who sprinkled lime in your basement to help out the smell.
Emily’s page would be private to everyone except her friends. Her friends would include people such as Colonel Sartoris, Homer Barron, and her cousins. These are the only people that she talks to besides the tax collectors that try to take her money. Her status is “married” because everyone thought that she and Homer Barron were going to get married until she poisoned him. The conversation between her neighbor and her would be taking place just after her father had passed away and she has him hoarded in her house.
Location: Yoknapatawpha County, Mississippi
Hobbies: In my free time I like to sit around my house, stare at people through my window and paint. I used to teach china painting classes to the younger kids of the town until I shut them out.
Status: I am “married” to a man named Homer Barron, he is a Yankee.
Wall Posts:
Neighbor: Dear Emily, I am really sorry to hear about your father he was a good man to this town. Best of luck to you! P.S. your house is starting to smell really bad, can you please get it checked?
Emily: My father isn’t dead and my house smells fine I don’t know what you could possibly be smelling.
Neighbor: You should thank those kind men who sprinkled lime in your basement to help out the smell.
Emily’s page would be private to everyone except her friends. Her friends would include people such as Colonel Sartoris, Homer Barron, and her cousins. These are the only people that she talks to besides the tax collectors that try to take her money. Her status is “married” because everyone thought that she and Homer Barron were going to get married until she poisoned him. The conversation between her neighbor and her would be taking place just after her father had passed away and she has him hoarded in her house.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)