Sunday, April 12, 2009

what do i really want?

In the dramatic monologue “My Last Duchess” the speaker, the duke, tells the story of his former wife. The way that the speaker talks tells a lot about him. His use of iambic pentameter tells you that he is a very controlling high ranking man. The fact that he uses curtains to hide the picture also conveys this idea of control, he is the only person who can control who sees the picture on the wall. The duke also seems to be a jealous person when it comes to his duchesses. The way he talks about his last duchess and the men that she would smile at or “thank” in some way shows that he is jealous but he doesn’t want to put himself low enough to admit it. He shows this when he says “…E’en then would be some stooping; and I choose never to stoop.” This could mean that he thinks very highly of himself as well.
In “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” which is also a dramatic monologue the speaker, J. Alfred Prufrock, is a very self conscious man who is afraid to confront people about anything. His physical features support his thoughts when he describes “a bald spot in the middle of my hair” or his thin arms and legs. He also mentions how he is getting older but it never says how old he actually is. In the line after his statement of him growing old he states that “I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled” implying that he is wearing his clothes in such a style that stereotypical old people might wear. He is the type of person that likes to keep to themselves whenever they can. He longs for the company of a woman but even in his fantasies he can’t even get a woman to do what he wants. Prufrock is under the impression that he will be lonely for the rest of his life when he says “I do not think they will sing for me” when he is talking about the mermaids. The mermaids is this monologue could be like sirens where they will sing and try to seduce anyone o come to them no matter who they are, but Prufrock seems to think that they will never sing for him because he is that undesirable.
Prufrock and the Duke share one common quality about them, They both long for something. The Duke was longing for control over his wife and he did not receive this until his wife was gone and the only thing left was her picture. Prufrock logs for the company of a woman in his life. In the monologue he never achieves this goal but he still longs for it.

2 comments:

  1. I thought your descriptions of the Duke and Prufrock's monologues really built the case for your conclusion. It's easy to point out the differences in the two characters (one being extremely controlling and arrogant, the other suffering from low self-esteem and lacking control of his life) but not so easy to build a connection between the two. Nice job.

    Just a quick note, there are a few typos. You may want to proofread it again. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really liked the connection you made between the two speakers from two different poems, both wanted something they never really got in the end... the reasons why are interesting because of their extreme personality types, one thinking too highly of himself, and one not thinking anything of himself!

    ReplyDelete